The fall of the House of Murdoch
Editor Note: Jonathan moncler sale online Schell is a Fellow at The Nation Institute and is a visiting fellow at Yale University. For more from Schell, cheap moncler jackets womens visit Project Syndicate website, or check it out on Facebook and Twitter.
During the four decades since the Watergate moncler outlet sale affair engulfed US President Richard Nixon, politicians have repeatedly ignored the scandal’s main lesson: the cover moncler sale up is worse than the crime. Like Nixon, they have paid a higher price for concealing their misdeeds than they would have for the misdeeds alone.
Now, for once, comes a scandal that breaks that rule: the United Kingdom’s phone hacking affair, which has shaken British politics to its foundations. Over the past decade, the tabloid newspaper The News of the World, owned by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, targeted 4,000 people’s voicemail. The list includes not only royalty, celebrities, and other VIPs, but also the families of servicemen killed in Afghanistan and Iraq, and those of victims of the July 2005 terrorist attack in London.
It all unraveled when The Guardian reported that the tabloid had hacked into the voicemail of missing 13 year moncler sale outlet old Milly Dowler, apparently in the hope of obtaining some private expressions of family members’ grief or desperation that it could splash on its front page. When the girl’s murdered body was found six months later, the family and the police thought she might still be alive, because The News of the World’s operatives were deleting messages when her phone’s mailbox became full. (According to Scotland Yard, Murdoch hacks reportedly bribed mid level police officers to supply information as well.)
In the extensive annals of eavesdropping, all of this is something new. Not even Stalin wiretapped the dead.
A cover up ensued. Millions of in house emails reportedly have been destroyed. Still, it seems cheap moncler coats mens safe to say that the peculiarly repellant inhumanity of the original deeds will remain more shocking than the details of this or any other cover up.
Even so, the political consequences of the phone hacking scandal will depend on far more than the outcome of the official investigations now underway in Britain. Above all, the scandal’s impact will depend on how governments and citizens assess what News Corporation really is.
The Murdochs call News Corporation a journalistic enterprise. In fact, it is, first, moncler womens jackets an entertainment company, with the bulk of its revenue coming from its film and television holdings. Second, and more importantly, it is a propaganda machine for right wing causes and political uk moncler outlet figures. Whereas political propaganda had once been the domain of governments and political parties, Fox News is formally independent of both though it overwhelmingly serves the interests ofAmerica’s Republican Party.
In Britain, News Corporation has been creating a sort of state unto itself by corrupting the police, assuming police powers of moncler online store surveillance, and intimidating moncler outlet prices politicians into looking the other way.
All ofthis is far removed from what a journalistic organization is supposed to do. Journalism’s essential role in a democracy is to enable people to fulfill their roles as citizens by providing information about government, other powerful institutions, civil movements, international events, and so on. But News Corporation replaces such journalism with titillation and gossip, as it did when it took over the 168 year old News of the World and turned it moncler uk outlet into a tabloid in 1984, and with partisan campaigns, as it moncler outlet did when it created Fox News in 1996.
Not surprisingly, at Fox News, as at many other News Corporation outlets, editorial independence is sacrificed to iron fisted centralized control. News and commentary are mingled in an uninterrupted stream of political campaigning. Ideology trumps factuality. And major Republican figures, including possible contenders for the party’s presidential nomination, are hired as “commentators.” Indeed, its specific genius has been to turn propaganda into a popular and financial success.
Given The News of the World’s profitability, no one should be surprised if the Murdochs have been replicating their sunken British flagship’s reprehensible behavior elsewhere. But, whatever else is revealed, the UK phone hacking scandal is of a piece with the Murdochs’ transformation of news into propaganda: both reflect an assault on democracy’s essential walls of separation between media, discount moncler jackets the state, and political parties. The Murdochs are fusing these entities into a single unaccountable power that, as we see in Britain today, lacks any restraint or scruple.
That effort should compel us to confront an uncomfortable reality underlying both the British phone hacking scandal, with its penumbra of appalling cruelty and wanton corruption, and Fox News, America’s most popular news channel: too many people want what the News Corporation has been offering. And what too many people want can be dangerous to a civilized, law based society.
To glimpse just how dangerous, consider Italy, where Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi’s MediaSet conglomerate has seduced broad swathes of the electorate since the 1980’s with a Murdoch like combination of insipid variety shows and partisan political theater. WhenItaly’s postwar party system collapsed in the early 1990’s, Berlusconi was able to establish his own political party, win power, and, over the course of three governments, bend laws and government institutions to serve his business and personal interests.
The News Corporation seems determined moncler outlet store to take Britain and the US down a similar path. But now, at least in Britain, the political class is in revolt. Prime Minister David Cameron who previously cultivated close ties with cheap moncler jackets mens NewsCorporation leaders, even employing as his cheap moncler sale press secretary The News of the World’s former editor, who was recently arrested for his role in moncler outlet online the scandal called the phone hacking “disgusting.” Meanwhile, Labour leaders, who had also sought the Murdochs’ favor, have vowed to block News Corporation’s bid for full ownership of Britain’s largest pay television broadcaster. Whether the rebellion will jump across the Atlantic remains to be seen.
The views expressed in this article are solely those of Jonathan Schell.
He not American. He is a right wing Australian. Australia is mostly a right wing, conservative country. The fallacy in everyone logic is that this is an American uk moncler sale plot. It is not. Much like Adolf Hilter was Austrian and not German, Murdoch has been pushing Australian values onto the world scene hiding it behind the facade of formerly United States based enterprises. People should look past the kangaroos, koalas, and Crocodile Dundee facade and see the very dangerous country is has become.
July 13, 2011 at 7:35 am moncler outlet woodbury Reply
hey there and thanks for your info? I certainly picked up something new from right here. I did on the other hand expertise some cheap moncler jackets technical points using this website, since I skilled to reload the site a lot of instances previous moncler usa to I may just get it to load correctly. I were thinking about if your hosting is OK? Not that I complaining, however slow loading cases instances will sometimes impact your placement in google and can harm your quality ranking if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Well I am including this RSS to my e mail and can glance out for much extra of your respective intriguing content. Ensure that you replace this once more very soon.
Fareed Zakaria GPS TVEvery week we bring you in depth interviews with world leaders, newsmakers and analysts who break down the best moncler jackets world’s toughest problems.